Skip to the article
tiny systems coTHE JOURNALING WIKI

decorate a memo,
save a moment.

LETTERING & COLOR

See What Changes When Pencil Layers Change Order

Compare four matching swatches before choosing a light-layer recipe for a journal accent.

A pale pencil does not always cover a dark one. Layer order, pressure, and paper can change the result. Four small swatches separate those questions so you can choose a controllable combination for a journal detail without chasing a prescribed number of layers.

TRY THIS FIRSTAbout 20 minutes

Find a pencil mixture you would like to use on one small tab.

  1. Pick yellow and blue pencils and one sheet of paper. Draw four 20 mm squares in a two-by-two grid so the comparisons can sit together.
  2. Label the top pair yellow then blue and blue then yellow; repeat below with “firmer finish.” Apply light first layers with visible paper texture.
  3. Add the other color with similar light passes. Compare the top pair and leave it untouched.
  4. Finish the lower-left more firmly with blue and lower-right with yellow. Stop if the surface turns slick or stops accepting useful color.
  5. Use the preferred light recipe on a 30 mm by 15 mm drawn tab, leaving a pale top strip and placing its label beside it.
Walk through it with us
Only the two bottom squares receive a firmer final pass
Only the two bottom squares receive a firmer final pass Open the diagram
Read the words in this diagram
  • Compare a firmer finish
  • Yellow then blue
  • Blue then yellow
  • Firmer blue finish
  • Firmer yellow finish
In this guide
Gather a few things See what you’ll need
  • Two colored pencils
  • Pencil sharpener
  • Paper
  • Pencil and ruler
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read

Choose colors with a visible relationship

Choose yellow and blue, or another pair you want to combine, and sharpen them. Use the same paper for all four swatches. Carrie L. Lewis explains how pressure, point, and surface affect layering; here you will change order first, then finishing pressure. If you change the paper too, you will have another possible reason for any difference.

Compare the optionsSeparate order from pressure
Compare the options

Separate order from pressure

Reverse the colors before changing the finishing pressure.

Four squares begin with matching light first layers in the two ordersTwo first layersYellow then blueBlue then yellowFirmer blue finishFirmer yellow finish
Read the words in this example
  • Two first layers
  • Yellow then blue
  • Blue then yellow
  • Firmer blue finish
  • Firmer yellow finish

Four squares begin with matching light first layers in the two orders

The left pair begins yellow and the right pair blue; all four first layers stay light.

Now try it on your paper.

Draw four 20 mm squares in a two-by-two grid with enough space for short labels. Label the top row “yellow then blue” and “blue then yellow.” Give the bottom row the same labels with “firmer finish” added. Make all four first layers with light, overlapping marks. Leave some paper texture visible instead of forcing immediate solid coverage. The two bottom swatches should begin just like their top partners. This setup gives you a direct comparison rather than four unrelated attempts made with increasingly different pressure.

ONE WORKED EXAMPLE

A pale tab beside the date

You want a yellow-and-blue accent for a journal date. You have two pencils and one paper, but no saved mixture you know how to repeat.

Before

An unlabeled patch has several layers and changing pressure. You cannot tell which part of the process produced the surface you prefer.

After

Four labeled 20 mm squares keep the two orders and the firmer finishes separate. For this example, the chosen top-row sample becomes a 30 × 15 mm tab with a pale upper strip and a dark date written beside it.

What changed—and what to check

The paired samples make the choice traceable. The small tab uses the chosen light recipe rather than turning the test sheet into a rule.

Try this check. Find the tab’s matching sample and check that its labels identify both the color order and finish.

Reserve four matching swatches

Draw four 20 mm squares in a two-by-two grid with label space. Across the top, write “yellow then blue” and “blue then yellow”; repeat below with “firmer finish.” Begin all four with light overlapping marks and visible paper texture. Lower squares should match their upper partners initially so you have paired comparisons rather than four increasingly different applications.

Add the second color lightly

Add blue over the yellow-first squares and yellow over the blue-first ones with similar light passes. Turn the paper if that helps your strokes lie evenly. Compare the top pair now and leave it alone. “Almost the same on this paper” is a useful result too; you need not keep layering until the samples look different.

See the differenceKeep the first comparison light
See the difference

Keep the first comparison light

Move the reveal control to inspect this specific change.

Dense first layers change pressure before order can be comparedPressure changes too soonReverse the second colorsYellow then blueBlue then yellowFirmer blue finishFirmer yellow finish
Read the words in this example

Dense first layers

  • Pressure changes too soon

Dense first layers

Both order and pressure changed, so the comparison is unclear.

Now try it on your paper.

Draw a 30 mm by 15 mm tab-shaped patch on a fresh area, using the top-row recipe you prefer. For this example, choose yellow first and a light blue layer afterward, leaving a slightly paler strip along the top. Keep the same pencil pressure you used in the successful swatch. Add a short dark label beside the patch rather than over an uncertain dense surface. The tab is a color accent drawn on paper; it doesn't need to be a physical attachment for the layering comparison to have a useful destination.

Compare a firmer last pass

Give the lower-left square a firmer final blue pass and the lower-right a firmer yellow pass, leaving the top untouched. Dense finishing may reduce tooth and change color while leaving less room for later layers. Primary pencil tutorials describe heavy-pressure burnishing as a distinct finishing choice. Stop if the surface becomes slick or no longer accepts useful color; the comparison does not require damage.

Choose a recipe for a small tab shape

Draw a 30 mm by 15 mm tab-shaped patch on fresh paper with your preferred top-row recipe. This example uses yellow then light blue, leaving a paler strip along the top. Match the successful swatch’s pressure. Put a short dark label beside the patch rather than on a dense untested surface. The tab is a drawn color accent, so it needs no physical attachment.

Write your versionWrite your layering recipe
Write your version

Write your layering recipe

Your paper and pencils may show a subtle difference; record that honestly.

AN EXAMPLE — MAKE IT YOURS

Pencil pair:Yellow and blue on this paper

Recipe selected:Yellow first, then a light blue layer

Your words have a place now.

Your paper and pencils may show a subtle difference; record that honestly.

Words on this card
17
Now try it on your paper.

Use this completed note beside the worked example. On the bottom-left square, make a firmer final pass with blue; on the bottom-right, use yellow. Keep the top pair untouched. A dense final application may reduce visible paper texture and change the color, but it can also leave less room for later adjustments. Heavy-pressure burnishing is a distinct finishing choice described in primary pencil tutorials, not a requirement for every layered drawing. Stop if the surface becomes slick or the pencil stops depositing useful color. The test should show a difference without requiring you to damage the paper.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERKeep a heavy first layer from setting the whole plan

Keep a heavy first layer from setting the whole plan

If the first layer is already dense, keep it as a heavy-base sample and restart lightly. Do not add pressure just to force another color to show. Try a different pair in fresh cells for an unwanted gray mixture. Test any eraser separately; lifting varies by paper and pencil. Keep unsuccessful samples with brief notes as evidence of the process.

Try a what-ifA favorite mixture changed in the journal
Try a what-if

A favorite mixture changed in the journal

Keep the useful comparison while changing papers.

A SITUATION TO THINK THROUGH

A light yellow-then-blue recipe looks soft on a rough scrap. On the smoother journal paper, the first trial looks denser.

Compare the three choices

What would help you choose the next pass?

  1. Make a fresh light trial on the journal paper and compare it with the saved sample

    The paper changed, so begin with room for adjustment. Note that surface with the recipe rather than forcing an exact match.

  2. Press harder until it resembles the rough-paper sample

    More pressure can close the surface further. It does not restore the texture of the earlier paper.

  3. Reverse the colors and add the firmer finish at once

    That may give a result you like, but changing order and pressure together will make the cause harder to identify.

A recipe belongs to its paper as well as its pencils.

What would you try?

Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.

Now try it on your paper.

Label the paper beside a useful swatch. If the next page uses another surface, try the light mixture there before filling a larger area.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERSave a visible recipe and stop

Save a visible recipe and stop

Keep the four squares together and label the pencils, paper and preferred order: for example, “yellow then blue, light layers.” A pass count can remind you how you made this sample, without becoming a rule for other pencils. Slip it beside the journal you intend to use; if that paper differs, make one fresh trial before coloring the heading.

Where this idea began

The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.