Gather a few things See what you’ll need
- A notebook page
- A pen
- One recent event or experience
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read
Choose questions that depend on one another
Use “What happened?”, “What do I make of that?” and, optionally, “What might I try or notice next?” Each answer supplies the next question’s material.
The University of Edinburgh explains “What? So what? Now what?” and its earlier development by Borton, Driscoll and others. Community monthly-review discussions seek usable structures. This journal adaptation keeps the connection without an assessed or comprehensive reflection.
Compare the optionsFollow the sign through three connected questions
Follow the sign through three connected questions
Each answer supplies material for the question after it.
Read the words in this example
- 1 / WHAT HAPPENED?
- People missed the flat sign.
- I stood it against a box.
The first rung records a visible change.
Start with what happened at the table.
ONE WORKED EXAMPLE
A sign changes the next question
A reader is reflecting on helping at a book swap. They want something more useful than a verdict about whether they were good at running the table.
Before
The entry says “I need to communicate better,” but gives no event or detail that could suggest what to try next.
After
They record the flat sign, two visitors asking whether books were free, and the next visitor reading after the sign was propped up. Then: “I had focused on wording; viewing angle mattered here. Next time I will check the sign from the approach path.”
What changed—and what to check
The entry now names the observation behind its interpretation. Its next step tests a specific feature without claiming that every sign needs the same angle.
Try this check. Underline the scene detail that supports your final thought; if none fits, narrow the thought or keep it as a question.
Put a small scene on the first rung
Bring “this week” down to one moment: making a sign, arriving at class, or sharing a task. Say where you were, what you tried, and what happened before asking what it means.
“I moved the sign twice before anyone noticed it” gives you something to examine. If “I'm bad at communicating” arrives first, keep it as a thought and look for the scene underneath. The event can tell you more than the broad verdict.
“Each answer supplies the next question’s material.”
Let the second answer stay close to the first
Choose one detail from the scene that matters to you now. “I had assumed…” or “What surprised me was…” can help connect an interpretation to something that actually happened.
If a next step follows, make it small: an action, a request for information, or something to notice next time. You can also write “No next step yet.” A reflection can end with a better question before it offers an answer.
Write your versionBuild a connected three-rung entry
Build a connected three-rung entry
Try the sign example or replace it with your own small event.
People asked about the swap table while the sign lay flat.
I had focused on the words and overlooked the viewing angle.
Next time I’ll look from the approach path first.
Your words have a place now.
A next move is optional; do not add a task merely to complete the structure.
- Words on this card
- 31
GO A LITTLE FURTHERClimb the ladder with a display sign
Climb the ladder with a display sign
Scene: “At the swap table, I put the sign flat beside the books. Two people asked whether they could take a book. I stood the sign against a box, and the next person read it before choosing.” Meaning: “I had been thinking about the wording, but the angle mattered too.”
Next: “At the next table, I’ll look at the sign from the approach path before changing the text.” The action follows this observation without prescribing an angle for every sign.
Try a what-ifTwo changes happened at once
Two changes happened at once
Decide what this small scene can establish.
At a craft table, you enlarged the instruction text and moved the instructions to the entrance at the same time. Fewer visitors asked where to start. You want to learn which change helped.
Compare the three choices
What is the most grounded reflection?
- Record the result after both changes, then compare one feature at a time in a later trial.
You observed fewer questions after both changes; this scene does not isolate either change or rule out other influences. A later comparison can investigate one feature while keeping others steady.
- Conclude that larger letters were responsible because they were more noticeable to you.
Your impression is worth recording, but the location also changed. This event does not separate letter size from placement.
- Conclude that the entrance location was responsible because visitors passed it first.
That is a plausible explanation to investigate. The larger text is another possibility, so keep the explanation tentative.
When several things change together, record the result separately from an explanation you have not tested.
What would you try?
Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.
Rescue a leap from one event to a verdict
When an answer contains “I always” or “I never,” return to the scene and ask how much it supports. “In this instance…” or “I don't yet know whether…” can preserve the thought without turning one occasion into a general rule.
Scale any next step to what you learned. “Read the sign from the doorway” follows a visibility problem; “improve all my communication” is too broad to guide the next attempt. Keeping the observation alone is also a useful ending.
GO A LITTLE FURTHERChange the ladder for a different subject
Change the ladder for a different subject
For reading: “Which passage stayed with me?”, “What did it make me question?”, “What would I like to read beside it?” For making: “What changed while I worked?”, “What did that reveal?”, “What would I repeat or alter?”
Keep the same material across the questions. A passage needn’t lead to redesigning your week; a new subject can have another entry.
Compare the optionsChoose a ladder for your material
Choose a ladder for your material
The questions change together so that the answers remain connected.
Read the words in this example
- START
- Which passage stayed with me?
- FOLLOW
- What would I read beside it?
Start from a passage and follow your question.
The last rung can be further reading.
GO A LITTLE FURTHERStop at the rung that gives you enough
Stop at the rung that gives you enough
Read upward from your final sentence to the original scene. Can you point to the detail that led there? If a link is missing, add the connection or leave the unsupported conclusion out.
Keep the question wording if it helped you write, and adapt it for another subject later. Stop with the scene and the meaning you recognize; the three answers need neither equal space nor a task in every final box.
Something for a future page?
The Washi Tape ShopAffiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Where this idea began
The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.
- Community discussionDo you do monthly reviews? What sort of prompts/layouts do you include?
Participants discuss prompts for reviewing a period, including what to start, stop and continue.
- Method referenceWhat? So what? Now what? — University of Edinburgh
Distinguishes describing an experience, considering its meaning and deciding what follows.



