Gather a few things See what you’ll need
- A notebook page or simple document
- A pen or keyboard
- A short passage, observation or remembered remark
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read
Give each side a clear job
Draw a loose division or use a two-column document. Label the sides “Line or observation” and “My response”; give more room to whichever needs it.
Utah State University teaches double-entry journals for pairing reading with connections and questions. A bullet-journal discussion pairs books with personal responses. This adaptation brings that neighboring response into a personal notebook.
Compare the optionsGive the same observation three possible responses
Give the same observation three possible responses
The starting material stays fixed while the writer tries different kinds of reflection.
Read the words in this example
- OBSERVATION
- Pencil guides
- stayed visible.
- MY RESPONSE
- I usually erase
- mine immediately.
A response can connect the observation to your practice.
The writer adds something personal.
ONE WORKED EXAMPLE
A source note gains a personal response
A reader is recording a lettering demonstration where pencil guidelines stayed visible on the finished piece. They want to keep their own response alongside what they observed.
Before
The left column records the visible guides. The right says only “the pencil lines were not erased,” repeating the same information.
After
Left: “Tuesday’s lettering demonstration: the instructor left the guidelines visible.” Right: “I erase mine immediately. I liked seeing how the letters were built, and I wonder which marks I remove from habit.” The writer keeps the instructor’s reason separate because it was not stated.
What changed—and what to check
The right column now adds a connection, preference, and question. It describes the writer’s response without turning that response into a claim about the instructor.
Try this check. Cover the starting item and ask what your response adds: a connection, a question, or a reason you noticed it.
Keep enough context to identify the starting material
For reading, note the title and page or section. Quote only the short phrase you need, or label your own wording as a summary. For remembered speech, identify the speaker with an initial or description and write “roughly” when the words are uncertain.
An action you saw is an observation: “The instructor left the pencil marks visible.” Add the place and date without quotation marks that would make it look like speech. The label helps you tell what you know from what you remember or infer.
“The instructor’s reason remains unknown unless asked separately.”
Respond to the particular line, not the whole subject
Answer the particular starting item. Why did it catch you? What does it connect with, or leave you wondering? “This reminds me of…” and “I'm not sure whether…” are enough to begin.
Keep the response alongside its source. Start the next pair below whichever side runs farther down the page, so an expanding response cannot drift beside the wrong prompt. The two sides can have different lengths and need no ruled grid.
Write your versionMake one source-and-response pair
Make one source-and-response pair
Use an observation, a short quotation or an honestly labeled summary.
The instructor left the pencil guidelines visible.
Tuesday’s lettering demonstration — my observation.
I usually erase mine. I wonder which marks I remove only from habit.
Your words have a place now.
Keep exact quotations distinct from remembered gist and from your own words.
- Words on this card
- 26
GO A LITTLE FURTHERRead a complete paired entry
Read a complete paired entry
Invented workshop example. Left: “Tuesday’s demonstration: the instructor left the pencil guidelines on the finished lettering.” Right: “I usually erase the construction lines immediately. Seeing them here made the letters feel made by a person rather than printed. I wonder which marks I remove because they are distracting and which I remove simply because I think finished work must hide its process.”
The response records the writer’s preference and question. The instructor’s reason remains unknown unless asked separately.
Try a what-ifA growing response drifts into the next row
A growing response drifts into the next row
Keep the relationship clear as one side gets longer.
Your first response takes six lines, but its source takes two. You start the second source immediately below those two lines, so it sits beside the end of the first response.
Compare the three choices
What will make the pairs easier to follow?
- Shorten every response until both columns use the same number of lines.
Equal lengths are unnecessary and could remove a useful thought. The pairs need aligned starting places, not matching word counts.
- Continue filling the left column and rely on the order of the entries.
Order helps, but the neighboring text will still suggest the wrong pairing when you scan the page later.
- Start the second pair below the longer first response, leaving space on the shorter side.
The gap keeps each source beside its own response. If the current page is already filled, a clear separator and matching pair labels can restore the connection.
Begin the next pair below the longer side so visual neighbors remain meaningful neighbors.
What would you try?
Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.
If the response only repeats the source
Read the right side with the left side covered. Does it add something of yours? “The guidelines were visible” repeats the observation; “I usually erase mine” connects it to your practice. A question or a reason for noticing also adds a response.
If nothing comes, leave a blank or “No response yet.” Try a shorter excerpt or another item when you want to continue. Copying more source text may use the space without giving you a more specific starting point.
GO A LITTLE FURTHERLet one pair lead beyond the columns
Let one pair lead beyond the columns
After two or three pairs, choose one to follow in a full-width paragraph beneath the columns. The construction-marks question could lead to your own lettering or another object you made.
Colorado State University’s double-entry assignment also keeps commentary alongside prior writing. The pair can start a longer response; you can leave the column when the thought outgrows it.
Compare the optionsIdentify what kind of material starts the pair
Identify what kind of material starts the pair
The source label changes with the material.
Read the words in this example
- LEFT LABEL
- Quotation + title + page
- RIGHT LABEL
- My response to that phrase
Exact wording needs a source reference.
Use only the phrase needed for your response.
GO A LITTLE FURTHERFinish with a source and a response you can reconnect
Finish with a source and a response you can reconnect
Check that exact quotations, summaries, observations, and your own responses are distinguishable. Add a missing title, date, page, or setting, then follow each row with your finger to check that the right response sits beside the right source.
One worthwhile pair can finish the page. If the same line prompts a new response later, date that addition and leave the first one readable. You will be able to reconnect both thoughts with the source and with when you wrote them.
Something for a future page?
The Washi Tape ShopAffiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Where this idea began
The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.
- Community discussionIdeas for 2020 trackers, lists, pages, reflections, etc.
The post includes books read with a short personal response; a reply describes lists of people or subjects to learn more about.
- Method referenceDouble-Entry Journal — Utah State University
Describes a reading method that pairs selected source material with the reader’s response in adjacent columns.
- Method referenceDouble Entry Journal Assignment Example — Colorado State University
Places a later reader response alongside earlier writing, keeping the material and commentary visibly distinct.



