Skip to the article
tiny systems coTHE JOURNALING WIKI

decorate a memo,
save a moment.

WRITING & REFLECTION

Record a choice before you know how it goes

Save your reasons, expectations and uncertainties, then compare them with a separately dated outcome.

Once an afternoon goes well—or badly—it can be hard to remember why the choice made sense beforehand. A brief decision entry saves that earlier view.

Try an ordinary choice, such as a drawing session versus a walk. Write before the result is known, then give the outcome its own dated note.

TRY THIS FIRST8 minutes now; 5 after the event

Save what made one ordinary choice reasonable before you know the result.

  1. Write the date and one undecided question, then name two or three options that are actually available to you.
  2. Note what matters today, what you know and what you’re assuming.
  3. Choose an option; record a recognizable expectation, one uncertainty and the tradeoff.
  4. After the event, add a new date, compare one expectation with reality and keep one useful observation.
Walk through it with us
A before-entry records reasons and expectations; a dated outcome is compared afterward.
A before-entry records reasons and expectations; a dated outcome is compared afterward. Open the diagram
Read the words in this diagram
  • BEFORE THE OUTCOME
  • Friday: try the open drawing session.
  • Reason: company and a starting point.
  • Expectation: finish one sketch.
  • AFTER THE SESSION
  • Saturday: half a sketch,
  • but two useful conversations.
  • REVIEW
  • The supplied subject helped me begin.
  • Finishing mattered less once there.
In this guide
Gather a few things See what you’ll need
  • A notebook or dated document
  • A pen or keyboard
  • One ordinary, low-stakes choice
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read

Pick a choice small enough to describe

Pick an undecided, specific question: “Will I spend Saturday afternoon at the open drawing session or take a walk?” Give it a date or occasion.

Community writers discuss structured columns for circling decisions. Farnam Street’s decision-journal method emphasizes recording reasons before the outcome. This version applies that timing to a manageable personal choice.

Compare the optionsKeep the decision and result in order
Compare the options

Keep the decision and result in order

The drawing-session example preserves what was known on each date.

Friday’s note records the reason and expectation.CHOICETry the open drawing session.EXPECTATIONFinish one sketch; meet othermakers.
Read the words in this example
  • CHOICE
  • Try the open drawing session.
  • EXPECTATION
  • Finish one sketch; meet other
  • makers.

Friday’s note records the reason and expectation.

It is written before attending.

Now try it on your paper.

Choose a low-stakes decision that has not happened yet.

ONE WORKED EXAMPLE

A lively café was not the quiet choice

You are choosing a place to write on Sunday: the library room or a familiar café. You check both opening times, but only assume the café will be quiet.

Before

After enjoying an unexpected conversation at the café, the draft declares the choice well researched, overlooking the untested expectation about noise.

After

Before: “Café; both places open. I expect quiet early and give up a larger library table.” After: “Music and conversation made writing difficult, but I enjoyed meeting a neighbor.” Review: the company was welcome; the quiet assumption failed and would need checking for a writing session.

What changed—and what to check

The pleasant outcome and the original reasoning can be examined separately. A welcome surprise does not retroactively supply evidence for the earlier assumption.

Try this check. Underline one expectation in the before-note and compare it with the outcome without rewriting the earlier words.

Write the options and what matters this time

Name two or three available options, including postponing or neither when possible. Record what matters this time: company, outdoors, drawing or quiet.

Separate information you have checked from what you expect. “The session starts at two” may be confirmed; “I will know someone there” is an assumption unless you have asked. Write what matters today beside those facts. A few plain sentences can show why company outweighs quiet this time without turning the choice into a score.

Describe an outcome you could recognize later

Write what you expect and why: “I expect to complete one sketch because the session has a set subject; I don’t know how crowded the room will be.” Make the expectation recognizable later.

Name the accepted tradeoff too. Choosing company may mean giving up the long walk; that absent benefit needn’t become a surprise afterward.

Write your versionWrite the before-entry
Write your version

Write the before-entry

Replace the example with an ordinary choice; keep uncertain information visibly uncertain.

AN EXAMPLE — MAKE IT YOURS

I’ll try the drawing session because I want company and a starting subject.

I expect one sketch; I don’t know how crowded the room will be.

I’m giving up the long walk. I’ll review after the session.

Your words have a place now.

Leave the actual outcome for a new, separately dated note.

Words on this card
37
Now try it on your paper.

Write this entry before making the choice, then add the outcome after it happens.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERRead a complete before-and-after entry

Read a complete before-and-after entry

Before, Friday: “I’ll try the open drawing session. I want company and a reason to use the sketchbook. I expect to finish one sketch because a subject is provided. I’m giving up the longer walk. I don’t know how busy the room will be.”

After, Saturday: “The room was busy and I made half a sketch. I liked hearing how two other people approached the subject. The supplied subject helped me start; finishing mattered less once I was there.” The review adds: “Next time I’ll describe what I want to try, not only what I expect to finish.”

See the differenceKeep a retrospective account honest
See the difference

Keep a retrospective account honest

Read the whole example before and after the change. The tinted lines show revised wording.

Tinted lines contain wording that differs between the two examples.

Before — Starting version

  • BACKFILLED
  • Friday: I knew the room would be busy.
  • WRITTEN
  • Actually written on Saturday.

After — Revised version

  • SATURDAY
  • Retrospective account
  • MEMORY
  • I think I expected a busy room.

Read the whole example before and after the change.

A reconstructed prediction is presented as if it were recorded beforehand. The date and label make the account’s limits clear.

Now try it on your paper.

If you write after the event, label the account retrospective and preserve uncertainty in your recollection.

Separate the result from the earlier reasoning

Read the before-entry before deciding what the result says about your thinking. Identify the known information, the assumptions, and anything that changed afterward. A good afternoon can contain an unsupported guess, just as a disappointing one can follow reasonable preparation. Review those parts separately rather than letting the ending rewrite the whole decision.

If you missed the before-entry, label the page “Retrospective account.” Record remembered reasons without inventing an earlier prediction.

Give the later review a narrow job

Review when the outcome is available: after the session, two uses of a new arrangement or finishing the borrowed book. Compare one expectation with what happened under a new date.

Ask what you’d want to know next time: enough tables? More conversation than finished work? “I’d choose the same option for the same reasons” can be the answer.

Try a what-ifThe option changes before the event
Try a what-if

The option changes before the event

Consider this page before choosing your next move.

A SITUATION TO THINK THROUGH

After writing your before-entry, you learn that the drawing session has been moved to a time you cannot attend. The event has not happened yet.

Compare the three choices

What should the record show?

  1. Wait until afterward and describe the original choice as a mistake.

    That would judge the choice using a schedule change you did not know when you made it.

  2. Add a dated update naming the new information and revised choice.

    Keep the original reasoning, then show why an option became unavailable before the outcome. The record can trace both decisions.

  3. Replace the original entry so only the latest choice remains.

    The current plan would be clear, but the reason it changed would disappear from the record.

When information changes, date the revision instead of silently rewriting what was known earlier.

What would you try?

Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.

Now try it on your paper.

If an undecided plan changes before its event, add the new fact and its date beside your earlier reasons.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERFinish without turning the journal into a judge

Finish without turning the journal into a judge

Keep one specific observation, such as “I enjoy a supplied starting point,” with room for different circumstances.

Keep the before-note and dated review together, then stop with one observation you can recognize again. “A supplied subject helps me begin” is more useful than awarding the decision a grade. You can leave the next ordinary choice unlogged; this record does not commit you to predicting every afternoon.

Where this idea began

The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.