Gather a few things See what you’ll need
- Three pens already available
- Known paper
- Pencil and ruler
- Protective scrap
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read
Choose what the grid needs to answer
Give the grid one question: “Which of these three pens makes a readable small date on this paper?” Keep the paper constant for that comparison. If you want to compare papers instead, use one pen throughout. Goulet’s paper comparison and the community discussion both point toward testing the combination you will actually use.
Compare the optionsBuild a useful swatch cell
Build a useful swatch cell
Add identification, repeated marks, and real writing.
Read the words in this example
- Same paper, same sample
- Blue
- Brown
- Gray
Reserve tool labels and sample cells
Reserve an identified cell for each tool before adding color.
ONE WORKED EXAMPLE
The rich patch is not the date line
You are choosing between blue, brown, and gray pens for small dates. The brown patch looks rich, but its thin writing sample is much paler beside black body text.
Before
You rank brown first from the filled patch, although the job you want it to do is a small handwritten date.
After
You read each dry “12 September” at your normal distance beside a black sentence. The grid records “brown patch richer than phrase.” You choose the clearest date-line sample for this page, keeping the other colors available for larger marks.
What changed—and what to check
The comparison now matches the intended application. A dense patch and a fine writing line can show the same ink differently.
Try this check. Cover the filled patches and choose again using only the dry phrases beside ordinary body writing.
Reserve labels before the color
Pencil three cells about 30 mm wide and 45 mm high with 5 mm gaps. Reserve each lower third for identification and notes. Label the paper above, using its name or “cream notebook, back test page.” Add a date if later additions need distinguishing. Ruled paper is suitable; its lines are part of the surface you actually intend to use.
Repeat a small set of useful samples
In each cell, repeat a short horizontal line, compact single-pass patch, and “12 September.” Write the phrase at normal pressure and speed. Put any second-pass patch beside the first and label it. Record tool differences: a broad marker and fine nib deposit different amounts of ink. Keeping their samples distinct avoids attributing every difference to color alone.
See the differenceCompare like applications
Compare like applications
Move the reveal control to inspect this specific change.
Read the words in this example
Unequal loads
There are no written words in this view. The explanation below describes what changes.
Unequal loads
Different patch sizes and loads obscure the comparison.
Compare three date-line candidates
Label blue, brown, and gray pens with exact names when known. Let dry and compare under the same light at your normal journal-reading distance. Choose brown for this example only if it remains distinct while sitting quietly beside black body writing. Your materials may favor another choice. The result is a documented decision about this date line, not a claim about all brown ink.
Record only what you actually observed
Write what you saw, such as “patch darker than phrase” or “reverse shows through.” An attractive patch does not answer whether small writing is clear. Leave untested properties blank; this exercise cannot establish permanence, waterproofness, or archival quality.
For smear timing, make separate marks for separate intervals and label the intervals. Repeatedly touching the same mark changes the thing you are trying to compare; surface shine alone does not tell you it is dry.
Write your versionWrite your swatch record
Write your swatch record
Record actual observations and unknown identities honestly.
Paper and tools:Cream notebook; blue, brown, gray pens
Question:Which color suits a small date?
Observation:Brown phrase stays distinct; patch is darker.
Your words have a place now.
Record actual observations and unknown identities honestly.
- Words on this card
- 24
GO A LITTLE FURTHERRecover an overfilled or mixed-up cell
Recover an overfilled or mixed-up cell
Label an oversaturated patch “multiple passes” and add a fresh normal-writing sample rather than comparing it with single-pass cells. Mark a forgotten identity “unknown” instead of guessing. If ink bleeds, protect the next sheet and switch to smaller writing tests. The damaged area can still document a combination needing lighter application; it does not need to become an attractive display.
Try a what-ifTwo colors came from different nibs
Two colors came from different nibs
Decide what this comparison can honestly tell you.
Your blue sample comes from a fine nib; the brown sample comes from a broad marker. Brown appears darker, and your note claims the brown ink itself is stronger.
Compare the three choices
What is the most useful revision?
- Label both tool widths and limit the claim to these pen-and-paper samples.
Both color and ink deposit may differ. The samples can help choose between these tools, but do not isolate a property of the inks alone.
- Compare only the largest filled patches.
The different tools and deposits still matter. A larger patch does not remove those differences.
- Remove the nib details to simplify the record.
Those details explain why the samples may differ. Removing them makes the stronger claim look better supported than it is.
Keep tool differences visible when they prevent a one-variable comparison.
What would you try?
Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.
GO A LITTLE FURTHERLet the chosen pen earn its place
Let the chosen pen earn its place
Use the selected pen for an actual date line beside your normal body writing. If it works differently there, note the difference on the grid instead of treating the swatch as a verdict.
Add a page reference where you keep pens or supplies. When a refill, pen, or paper changes, make a new labeled sample beside the old one so you can see which combination produced the earlier result.
Something for a future page?
The Washi Tape ShopAffiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Where this idea began
The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.
- Background mention — search excerpt onlyInk swatching on lined paper
This link provides background context. The full discussion was not reviewed, so it is not evidence that this exact method is popular or effective.
- Method referenceHow Inks Look on Different Papers
Demonstrates paper-and-ink comparisons using the same pen to hold one variable constant.



