Skip to the article
tiny systems coTHE JOURNALING WIKI

decorate a memo,
save a moment.

NOTEBOOK PRACTICES

Give Every Annotation a Reason

Use Question, Keep, and Connection to leave readable routes back into a text.

A heavily underlined page tells you something caught your attention. It may not tell you why. Begin with three written labels—Question, Keep, and Connection—and pair each mark with a few words you can use on a return visit.

TRY THIS FIRSTAbout 5 minutes

Leave one book note that tells you why you wanted to return.

  1. Write a bookmark key: Question = understand; Keep = find again; Connection = relate to another passage or idea.
  2. Read to the end of a paragraph, then choose one detail and label it with a reason, such as “Question: whose account is this?”
  3. In a borrowed or untouched book, put the page number and note on a separate slip. Use margins only in your own book if you are comfortable marking it.
  4. At a natural pause, revisit the note and answer, compare, or develop what it asks.
Walk through it with us
THREE MARKS, THREE JOBS. Original schematic example; method details shown on the page.
THREE MARKS, THREE JOBS. Original schematic example; method details shown on the page. Open the diagram
Read the words in this diagram
  • THREE MARKS, THREE JOBS
  • The market moves
  • indoors. The room
  • feels quieter.
  • Keep
  • Quieter sound, or
  • trade?
  • Question
  • Compare the
  • outdoor scene.
  • Connection
In this guide
Gather a few things See what you’ll need
  • A book or article
  • A pencil
  • A narrow scrap bookmark
  • A notebook
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read

Choose three jobs your reading needs

Start with three jobs: Question for something to understand, Keep for a detail to retrieve, and Connection for a link to another passage or idea. Write those meanings on a bookmark before adding colors. These are practice choices, not a standard you must follow. If sentence craft is your interest, Technique might serve you better than Connection.

Compare the optionsGive this mark a useful job
Compare the options

Give this mark a useful job

Choose a situation and notice how the example changes. Each choice gives a different useful next move.

THREE MARKS, THREE JOBS. Original schematic example; Market moves indoors.THREE MARKS, THREE JOBSThe market movesindoors. The roomfeels quieter.KeepQuieter sound, ortrade?QuestionCompare theoutdoor scene.ConnectionMarket moves indoors.
Read the words in this example
  • THREE MARKS, THREE JOBS
  • The market moves
  • indoors. The room
  • feels quieter.
  • Keep
  • Quieter sound, or
  • trade?
  • Question
  • Compare the
  • outdoor scene.
  • Connection
  • Market moves indoors.

Use Keep for the detail you need to locate.

Marking the market move gives you a route back to the event. Add the reason in a few words, so the mark is more useful than a color whose meaning you have forgotten.

Now try it on your paper.

Try one written annotation label with its reason on a loose bookmark before expanding your key.

ONE WORKED EXAMPLE

A question that an underline cannot ask

You are reading a borrowed novel and want to return to a description of a newly quiet market. You want to investigate the wording without marking the book itself.

Before

A bookmark at the page identifies the location, but gives no clue about which sentence interested you or what you wanted to examine.

After

A separate slip reads “Page 42, indoor market. Question: does ‘quieter’ describe the sound or the trade?” The passage stays unmarked, and the note gives a specific question to carry into the next reading session.

What changed—and what to check

The location and reason work together. The slip preserves access to the sentence while respecting a borrowed book’s unmarked pages.

Try this check. Remove the slip briefly, then use its page number and clue to find the exact passage again.

Decide where your marks can safely live

In a book you own and are comfortable marking, use a tiny margin label and underline the relevant words. For borrowed or untouched pages, put the page number and label on a separate slip; a plain bookmark avoids testing adhesives on someone else’s paper. Put long responses in a notebook and reference that page. Test pens on your own spare paper if show-through matters.

Add the reason beside the label

“Question: whose account is this?” explains more than the label alone. University of North Carolina annotation guidance encourages comments, questions, and summaries in your own words. Finish a paragraph before selecting a mark so you have its context. Then write a brief reason that will remain meaningful when you return.

See the differenceOne useful label
See the difference

One useful label

Read the whole example before and after the change. The tinted lines show revised wording.

Tinted lines contain wording that differs between the two examples.

Before — The note before revision

  • THE NOTE AS WRITTEN
  • CURRENT NOTE
  • Many underlines
  • WHAT IS MISSING
  • A usable detail or clear limit.

After — The note with a clearer record

  • THE NOTE AS WRITTEN
  • REVISED NOTE
  • Question: sound or trade?
  • WHY IT HELPS
  • One useful label

Read the whole example before and after the change.

Repeated underlining does not tell you why a passage mattered. The question names the ambiguity that a return reading can investigate.

Now try it on your paper.

Try one written annotation label with its reason on a loose bookmark before expanding your key.

Mark an invented paragraph three ways

In an invented paragraph, a village moves its market indoors during a wet month; a stallholder says the room feels quieter. Possible notes are “Keep: market moves indoors,” “Question: quieter in sound or in trade?” and “Connection: compare the crowded outdoor scene.” Try the labels in the interactive example, then choose whichever gives this passage a useful next question.

Write your versionDraft: Give Each Book Mark a Clear Job
Write your version

Draft: Give Each Book Mark a Clear Job

Edit the practice words to make a note you can use in your own notebook. Keep any uncertainty visible.

AN EXAMPLE — MAKE IT YOURS

Book and locationPractice paragraph, market scene.

Mark and reasonQuestion: does quieter mean sound or trade?

Return actionRead the next paragraph for context.

Your words have a place now.

The initial words are an invented practice example. Edit only the details you want to keep; your entry can stay short.

Words on this card
25
Now try it on your paper.

Try one written annotation label with its reason on a loose bookmark before expanding your key.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERReduce a key that has become work

Reduce a key that has become work

When choosing a category takes longer than writing the note, look at two labels you hesitate between. Could one ordinary phrase cover both? Merge them on a dated bookmark key and keep the old key with earlier notes if its meanings differ. If labels still interrupt reading, a single “Return here” plus a reason is enough.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERTurn one mark into something useful

Turn one mark into something useful

At a natural pause, read one mark’s reason before the passage. Answer its question, develop its connection, or carry the location into a response entry. Let an uninteresting old mark remain without turning cleanup into another project. A shared key can travel across books; use separate slips when a gardening text and novel need different categories.

Try a what-ifAn old color no longer means the same thing
Try a what-if

An old color no longer means the same thing

Keep earlier notes understandable after simplifying the key.

A SITUATION TO THINK THROUGH

You used blue for Connection in one book, then changed blue to Question for the next. You want to retain useful notes from both.

Compare the three choices

How can the key preserve that distinction?

  1. Recolor every old mark to match the new system.

    That may be possible on copies, but adds work and risks altering the old annotations unnecessarily.

  2. Keep dated keys with the relevant book notes.

    Each set of marks remains interpretable in the system used when it was made. New notes can use the simpler key.

  3. Use the latest blue meaning for every note.

    That would turn earlier connections into questions the notes may never have asked.

When a key changes meaning, preserve enough context to read the marks made under the old one.

What would you try?

Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.

Now try it on your paper.

Date your current bookmark key and keep an earlier version if existing annotations still depend on it.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERKeep the key only as long as it helps

Keep the key only as long as it helps

Before putting the book away, try following one note back into its paragraph. Can you tell what you wanted to find, question or compare? At the end of the book, keep the references that still lead somewhere useful. Transfer any response you want to retain before recycling its loose slip.

Where this idea began

The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.