Skip to the article
tiny systems coTHE JOURNALING WIKI

decorate a memo,
save a moment.

NOTEBOOK PRACTICES

Keep Book Pages Separate from Notebook Pages

Capture source details and passage locations that still make sense when you return.

The note says “page 42.” Was that the book or your notebook? Label both addresses while the source is open, and keep exact quotations separate from what you thought about them.

TRY THIS FIRSTAbout 5 minutes per source

Leave a note that can take you back to the right passage.

  1. Record the source’s author or organization, exact title, and edition, date, or URL as appropriate.
  2. Label the passage location explicitly: “book p. 42,” “handout p. 2,” chapter, section, or timestamp.
  3. Write your note as a labelled summary or an exact quotation, with your response separate.
  4. Use the reference to reopen the passage before closing the source. If you used a source code, check that it leads to full details.
Walk through it with us
A source record distinguishes the source location from the notebook location.
A source record distinguishes the source location from the notebook location. Open the diagram
Read the words in this diagram
  • Source card R3
  • Display Workshop / practice
  • Community hall / 12 October
  • Handout p. 2 / access notes
  • My notebook p. 16
In this guide
Gather a few things See what you’ll need
  • Notebook
  • Pen
  • Book, article, or handout
  • A place to save long URLs
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read

Record what a future search will need

For a book, record author, title, and edition or publication details where editions differ. For a handout, use title, author or organization, date if shown, and page. For a web article, keep author or organization, exact title, URL, and access date if content may change. Add the relevant chapter, section, page, or timestamp. These details aid retrieval without guaranteeing continued availability.

Compare the optionsInspect three parts of a source trail
Compare the options

Inspect three parts of a source trail

Which record would you like to follow?

A source record distinguishes the source location from the notebook location.Source card R3Display Workshop / practiceCommunity hall / 12 OctoberHandout p. 2 / access notesMy notebook p. 16
Read the words in this example
  • Source card R3
  • Display Workshop / practice
  • Community hall / 12 October
  • Handout p. 2 / access notes
  • My notebook p. 16

R3 identifies the full practice source.

The source page and notebook page are labelled separately.

Now try it on your paper.

Open one real source and record the information needed to return to the passage.

ONE WORKED EXAMPLE

Page 42 belongs to the book

You have a reading note on notebook page 16 that discusses a passage on page 42 of a book. The shorthand reference contains only the number 42.

Before

On rereading, you cannot tell which book supplied the passage or whether 42 is a source page or another notebook page.

After

The note now carries the book’s author, title, and relevant edition details, followed by “book p. 42.” Its location in your own index is “notes p. 16.” Your summary and separate response remain beneath the source reference.

What changed—and what to check

Naming each address removes an ambiguity the numbers cannot solve alone. The full source record gives the book page a specific document to belong to.

Try this check. Use the reference to open the book passage, then find the same note through the notebook’s own page address.

Label source pages and notebook pages separately

Use labels such as “book p. 42” and “notes p. 16.” Both numbers can be correct while leading to different places. Write the source label even when your notebook already has printed page numbers.

For an ebook, keep a chapter or section clue alongside any location number and identify the edition. Screen pages can change; the useful reference is the one that lets you find the same passage again.

Write your versionWrite two unambiguous locations
Write your version

Write two unambiguous locations

Edit the worked example into a note you can use.

AN EXAMPLE — MAKE IT YOURS

Source:R3: practice workshop handout

Source location:Handout p. 2

Notebook location:Notes p. 16

Your words have a place now.

A bare page number should not have to serve two books.

Words on this card
15
Now try it on your paper.

Add source and notebook prefixes to one old ambiguous reference.

“These details aid retrieval without guaranteeing continued availability.”
GO A LITTLE FURTHERShorten repeated references without hiding them

Shorten repeated references without hiding them

For repeated notes from one source, assign a code such as R3 in a source list containing full details. Write “R3, handout p. 2” on an individual note. For a single entry, the full title above the note may be simpler. Community commonplace discussions describe source and topic indexes as separate retrieval routes; either can stay brief.

Make a complete original example

Imagine an invented “Community Hall Display Workshop” handout dated 12 October, with access notes on page 2. Give it code R3 in the source list. On notebook page 16, write “R3, handout p. 2,” then “Summary: test a caption from the back row” and “My note: enlarge the sample before testing.”

The handout’s page 2 and notebook’s page 16 are distinct. Replace invented details with actual document information when using a real source; label anything unknown.

Decide what kind of note you are making

Before using quotation marks, compare the wording with the source. Exact copied wording and your own summary are different kinds of note. Keep your response in a separate sentence or paragraph so you can see where the source account ends.

If you omit or alter quoted words, make that visible as your work requires. Personal shorthand should retain enough information to verify later; a publication or course may also require a particular citation format.

See the differenceSeparate a summary from a response
See the difference

Separate a summary from a response

Read the whole example before and after the change. The tinted lines show revised wording.

Tinted lines contain wording that differs between the two examples.

Before — One mixed paragraph

  • A mixed note
  • Test from the back row
  • I should enlarge the caption

After — Two labelled voices

  • Note linked to R3
  • R3 / handout p. 2
  • Summary: test from back row
  • My note: enlarge caption
  • Notebook p. 16

Read the whole example before and after the change.

The reader cannot tell which thought belongs to the source. Labels distinguish the paraphrase from the keeper’s decision.

Now try it on your paper.

Mark an exact quote, a paraphrase, and your own response differently in words.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERPreserve a usable route when the URL is awkward

Follow one sentence all the way back

Choose one sentence in your note and reopen the passage it refers to. If you used R3 or another code, follow that code to its full source details as well. Add the missing clue wherever the route makes you guess.

Close the source only after this short check. A topic-index entry can provide another route later, but it cannot replace the source address needed to verify what the note says.

Try a what-ifThe saved link no longer opens
Try a what-if

The saved link no longer opens

Keep the note’s origin distinct from a useful replacement reading.

A SITUATION TO THINK THROUGH

Your old article URL is unavailable. Searching its title finds a newer article on a similar topic by another author, but you have not found the original passage.

Compare the three choices

What should happen to the original reference?

  1. Keep its known details and label the original page unavailable.

    The note still came from that source. If the new article is useful, record it separately rather than changing the origin of an existing claim.

  2. Replace the old URL with the newer article’s link.

    That would make the newer author appear to support a passage you have not verified there.

  3. Remove the source details and keep the summary alone.

    Unavailable does not mean all provenance is lost. The original title, author, and date may still help a later search.

A similar source is additional reading, not a substitute origin for an existing note.

What would you try?

Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.

Now try it on your paper.

Test one saved reference. If it fails, retain the known details and mark what is unavailable before searching further.

Where this idea began

The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.

  • Community discussionFirst 100 Pages of My Commonplace Book

    A contributor considers separate source and topic indexes after a color classification proved unsatisfactory.

  • Practitioner exampleThe Book Log

    Book notes can retain exact source locations, distinguish quoted words, and use indexes or threading for retrieval.

    The author calls this approach a work in progress and says it had not been rigorously tested over a long period.

    Source checked 2026-09-05.