Skip to the article
tiny systems coTHE JOURNALING WIKI

decorate a memo,
save a moment.

NOTEBOOK PRACTICES

Give One Leaf Three Kinds of Attention

Separate what you notice, what you wonder, and what the subject reminds you of.

You write “green leaf,” then look again. One edge is curled. Three pale lines branch from the middle. Suddenly there's more on the page than a name.

Try three beginnings: “I notice,” “I wonder,” and “It reminds me of.” They'll help you keep what you can see, what you'd like to find out, and the connection that occurred to you.

TRY THIS FIRSTAbout 10 minutes

Look at one leaf three different ways.

  1. Choose a stationary subject you can view comfortably without disturbing it. Record date and location.
  2. Under “I notice,” write two features another observer could point to, with approximate counts labelled.
  3. Under “I wonder,” turn one feature into a question. Put any possible explanation under “Maybe.”
  4. Under “It reminds me of,” record a resemblance and the feature that prompted it.
  5. Choose a way to pursue one question, such as another viewpoint, a return visit, or a sourced reference check.
Walk through it with us
NOTICE / WONDER / REMINDS. Original schematic example; method details shown on the page.
NOTICE / WONDER / REMINDS. Original schematic example; method details shown on the page. Open the diagram
Read the words in this diagram
  • NOTICE / WONDER / REMINDS
  • NOTICE
  • Three gaps on one edge.
  • WONDER
  • When did they appear?
  • REMINDS ME
  • A folded paper fan.
In this guide
Gather a few things See what you’ll need
  • A notebook
  • A pencil
  • A natural object you can observe without disturbing it
  • A ruler if measurement is useful
Choose an exercise 4 things to try as you read

Choose something that will stay available

Choose a stationary subject visible from a comfortable position: a leaf on a plant, a stone beside a path, or a branch outside a window. Leave living things and unfamiliar objects in place. Record date and a retrievable location, such as “leaf on the low branch beside the gate.” Observe without leaning into traffic or damaging plants.

Compare the optionsKeep three kinds of attention separate
Compare the options

Keep three kinds of attention separate

Choose a situation and notice how the example changes. Each choice gives a different useful next move.

NOTICE / WONDER / REMINDS. Original schematic example; Three gaps along one edge.NOTICE / WONDER / REMINDSNOTICEThree gaps on one edge.WONDERWhen did they appear?REMINDS MEA folded paper fan.Three gaps along one edge.
Read the words in this example
  • NOTICE / WONDER / REMINDS
  • NOTICE
  • Three gaps on one edge.
  • WONDER
  • When did they appear?
  • REMINDS ME
  • A folded paper fan.
  • Three gaps along one edge.

Put the feature under Notice.

Three gaps along the leaf edge can be pointed out in the practice example. Record that visible feature before proposing an explanation; the observation does not identify what made the gaps.

Now try it on your paper.

Observe one nearby subject and write a detail, a real question, and a clearly labeled association.

ONE WORKED EXAMPLE

A dark stripe across a stone

From the path, you can see a pale stone beneath a railing. A dark stripe crosses its face, and you want to describe it without deciding immediately what made it.

Before

“The stone is wet” turns the darker area into an explanation before you have checked whether its boundary could be a shadow.

After

Notice: “A dark stripe crosses the pale face; one edge is nearly straight.” Wonder: “Does the stripe move as the sun moves?” Reminds me: “A bookmark laid across a page.” You record the viewpoint and leave the stone in place for a later look.

What changed—and what to check

The visible edge suggests something you could check later. The bookmark comparison describes its appearance without proving either wetness or shadow.

Try this check. Locate the stripe in your description and name what a later observation could establish that this one cannot.

Describe what the subject actually shows

Start with something another person could point to: “Three pale lines branch from the center.” Then look at an edge or the way two parts meet. “It needs water” is a possible explanation, so keep that for a question or a Maybe line. If a count is uncertain, say “about.” A rough drawing with labels can hold the details your pen cannot easily show.

“Put possible explanations under “Maybe,” apart from observations.”

Turn a detail into a real question

Let a feature produce a question. A curled edge might suggest “Is the other side curled too?” or “Does it look different after rain?” Some questions need a changed viewpoint, others a later visit or reference. Put possible explanations under “Maybe,” apart from observations. Shape, position, and change remain available questions even without a species name.

See the differenceObserve before explaining
See the difference

Observe before explaining

Read the whole example before and after the change. The tinted lines show revised wording.

Tinted lines contain wording that differs between the two examples.

Before — The note before revision

  • THE NOTE AS WRITTEN
  • CURRENT NOTE
  • An insect ate it
  • WHAT IS MISSING
  • A usable detail or clear limit.

After — The note with a clearer record

  • THE NOTE AS WRITTEN
  • REVISED NOTE
  • Three gaps; cause not established.
  • WHY IT HELPS
  • Observe before explaining

Read the whole example before and after the change.

Naming an insect invents a cause the leaf observation has not established. Visible gaps remain an observation while their cause stays open.

Now try it on your paper.

Observe one nearby subject and write a detail, a real question, and a clearly labeled association.

Try an invented leaf entry

This original practice entry reads: “I notice three small gaps along one edge and a pale line down the middle. I wonder whether the gaps were already there when the leaf opened. It reminds me of a folded paper fan, especially where the smaller lines spread outward.”

The fan is an association, not an identification or evidence for the gaps’ cause. Label a fan sketch as a connection rather than part of the observed leaf.

Write your versionDraft: Look Again With Notice, Wonder, and Reminds Me
Write your version

Draft: Look Again With Notice, Wonder, and Reminds Me

Edit the practice words to make a note you can use in your own notebook. Keep any uncertainty visible.

AN EXAMPLE — MAKE IT YOURS

I noticeThree gaps along one edge and a pale central line.

I wonderWere the gaps there when the leaf opened?

It reminds me ofA folded paper fan where the smaller lines spread.

Your words have a place now.

The initial words are an invented practice example. Edit only the details you want to keep; your entry can stay short.

Words on this card
35
Now try it on your paper.

Observe one nearby subject and write a detail, a real question, and a clearly labeled association.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERWhen you jump straight to naming things

When you jump straight to naming things

If the entry says only “oak leaf” or “bird,” cover the name and add two visible details. Move an unsupported explanation into a question and name what could check it. If a drawing misses a feature, write it: “edge has tiny teeth.” A corrected label can record more than repeated attempts at an outline.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERGive one question a next step

Give one question a next step

Choose the question you are most curious about. You might change your viewpoint without touching the subject, return to the branch, or check a field guide. If you want to compare the same leaf later, note which branch and which leaf now. Date anything you learn afterward and name its source; another person’s confident guess can stay a possibility while you check.

GO A LITTLE FURTHERFinish before the subject becomes an assignment

Finish before the subject becomes an assignment

Leave the notebook with one question you would enjoy returning to. You may notice its answer on a later walk, or find a different detail more interesting. The fan-like veins and the curled edge are already a record of this look; a species name does not have to finish it.

Try a what-ifThe return visit has several possible leaves
Try a what-if

The return visit has several possible leaves

A comparison needs the same subject.

A SITUATION TO THINK THROUGH

Your note says “curled leaf by the gate.” After rain, you return to a branch with five similar leaves and cannot tell which one you drew.

Compare the three choices

What can you honestly do next?

  1. Choose the most curled leaf and call it the same one

    Its current shape cannot establish which leaf you observed before. The selection could manufacture the apparent change.

  2. Compare the whole branch as though it were one leaf

    The branch can become a new subject, but its appearance cannot answer what changed in that particular unidentified leaf.

  3. Keep the first identity uncertain and locate a new subject precisely

    You can begin a clearer pair of visits now. Leave the earlier sketch as its own observation instead of forcing a match.

A precise place makes later comparison useful; similarity alone does not establish identity.

What would you try?

Choose an option to see what it would do. You can explore all three.

Now try it on your paper.

Add a retrievable location to one subject you may revisit, without moving or marking the living thing.

Where this idea began

John Muir Laws teaches “I notice,” “I wonder,” and “It reminds me of,” and credits inspiration from Kerry Ruef’s Private Eye Project. The leaf entry here is an invented practice example.

The method references explain the underlying ideas. Community links show the questions and experiences that helped shape this guide; they are not a popularity ranking. The worked examples here are our own.

  • Background mention — search excerpt onlyStill very very new to this

    This link provides background context. The full discussion was not reviewed, so it is not evidence that this exact method is popular or effective.

  • Background mention — search excerpt onlyJournaling Type Help/Prompts

    This link provides background context. The full discussion was not reviewed, so it is not evidence that this exact method is popular or effective.

  • Method referenceJohn Muir Laws and the Art of Paying Attention

    Laws explains Notice, Wonder, and Reminds Me and acknowledges inspiration from Kerry Ruef’s Private Eye Project.